January 24, 2013 at 7:57 PM (Uncategorized)

There was a wonderfully detailed post here

About disability and theology.

It’s got a lot of scholarly, theological backup, which I applaud.

It also acknowledges the social model of disability, which I applaud.

But it makes me twitchy.

I don’t know why, but it just does.

I don’t want to fight against it, or cheer it on…It’s a little too deep in intellectual heft for me to do that right now…my brain cells are presently fairly mushy….

I could be misinterpreting some of it, but I’m getting the vibe of it’s our differences *directly* related to our impairments that make us theologically significant…and that idea makes me twitch, because, well, my radio for speaking with God has sent me no such transmission.

But I do want to respond to this as a layperson with a disability who has been involved in many denominations in her lifetime.  I’ve been a mainline Protestant (Methodist, Presbyterian), been involved with, and lived by the strictures of the American Evangelical Protestant churches, been an agnostic and skeptic for great periods, and am now what I consider to be a fairly involved Catholic.  This post is meant as my own present belief, my own present spiritual truth

First, I know this will sound disrespectful to those of charismatic/Pentecostal faiths, and many of my fellow Catholics who see direct healing as something to seek out in healing services, prayer or pilgrimages to various shrines.    Can’t help that.  As CS Lewis said, no one is ever told any story but their own.

Here’s my first creepy absolutist statement that will bother some believers:

Charismatic believers: If someone asks you not to pray over them for physical healing,  refuses your request to do so, or is visibly uncomfortable with you doing so, LAY OFF.  God told me to tell you that that’s not how He wants it done.

[I used to hate the implied arrogance of that “God told me to tell you,” thing, the masking of unasked for advice from a very human person with a little God-frosting attached to it when used against me, but I gave myself a pass this one time. ]

1. I am now, at present, a believer.  I believe that God exists.

2. I also believe that direct miraculous, magical looking healing can take place from time to time…but that the only healing humans can do themselves is the rest-and-get-better for the mild stuff, and the medical, scientific sort for the heavy lifting.  The sudden sort, seems to me, is the province and ability of God alone.

(disagreement with these is cheerfully welcome.  I talk to everybody, and impose on none.)

I know of many persons with illnesses and disabilities who take great time, either praying and asking for direct healing, or sitting around being pissed off at God as a kind of permanent rage state, because theyr  have not been healed by God, and they believe He ought to have done it.

Here’s the part that feels really non-theological:  Both the rage and the pining after miracles, seem to me to be a waste of one’s life’s work, the path that God put you on in the first place.

If God chooses, he can and will handle healing someone.  God’s timeline, however, is often quite out of whack with human time.

I feel incredibly strongly that everybody has a talent in this world that is uniquely their own, able or disabled…separate from the impairment…maybe caused by parts of it but separate from it.  It may be harder to find, tougher to utilize or pursue if one has an impairment…but it’s out there….

It could be a very simple talent, like making others smile, or a complex talent  that reaches the level of employable skillset.  You don’t need to be able to move or work or speak like an able bodied person to have a talent.

If you’re a person of faith, you may perceive that such talents are given to you by God…

When I’ve listened for God’s advice, as well as sometimes actively prayed about this question, the message I’ve gotten is to actively use that talent as much as I can.

Here’s my   second creepy theological statement.

If you spend more time pining or raging for and about your own healing, instead of using the tool that God put in your hands, you aren’t spending that time doing the things God meant for you to do, simple or complex, short or long

And here’s my y third creepy seems-to-run-counter-to-much-theology statement.

Can persons with disabilities please not buy into the idea that us and our difference, or pain or illness, are out there to make us saints, martyrs, or little icons to inspire others to live a better life? Ewwww.

I know that there are many many stories, both biblical and otherwise (saints martyrs etc), where this is the role that even Jesus says ought to be used…but I think that revelation is completed by our works or talents…not by the impairment itself.  I always see those healing stories through the prism of “It’s God not just *saying* He can do anything, but *doing* it, more about some statement of omnipotence than the healing itself.)

If charity does sometimes get extended to us…at a point of need, we can be grateful….sometimes the able need that too, so a church serving a member with a disability is not a singled out task but a part of the broader spectrum of the church’s function, to minister to people who come with specific needs.

Well, then, the irritated reader says,  what *do* we pray for, if not healing.  When things get really bad, when our impairments threaten to overwhelm us, with either societal barriers, medical problems, massive chronic pain, any number of things that can hit us as a direct result of our impairments.


When I’ve actually taken the time to sit down and ask for the strength to endure, I get it. I’m human, I whine, but that idea of asking for the strength to endure something seems to be always in stock, stacked up and ready to go.

It’s not one of those things where we are forced to say, “Well, there are some things we were not meant to know…”  or, the anguished “Why,” that I’ve had to replace with a stiff, “I know there’s a point to all this….but I can’t discern it.  It’s all darkness to me, but I know there’s a blueprint somewhere…”

Endurance seems to have all the constancy in availability that physical healing does not.

I’ve also had some success running a bit of a self diagnostic…”What’s really crying out here?  is it your body, your mind or your soul that’s looking for healing?

All of that said:

There is some actual  evidence (studies have been done.)  that when you pray for someone else to be healed, in whole or in part, benefit *does* redound to them, sometimes in nearly complete ways.

There are always stories of doctor’s shaking their heads as some massive cancer that had no business leaving the building at all, is no longer present in diagnostic scans etc.

Hmmm.  The *direction* and intent of the prayer seems to matter a bit.

I think this type of prayer can bring great comfort in the worst of the worst situations, ICU hospitalizations etc… to the person praying, and release for the person prayed for, when the physical pain is at hideous extremes near the end of life, or after some huge illness or injury:

Well, okay…read the first article because it really is deep and interesting, even if it makes me twitchy.

Here endeth the sermon.



  1. Ruth Harrigan said,

    Great post. Something about it made me twitchy too. I’ve spent time thinking about these things…I would add that ‘spiritual healing’ as opposed to physical healing…is something all of us ..disabled, nondisabled need at times. That, to me, is a more useful way to think about healing while at the same time acknowledging that I’m getting on with my life as it is and pretty well too.

    • imfunny2 said,

      I’m more comfortable (or cowardly, LOL) with indirect, I suppose…but your post really makes me miss my days in academia when I could have borrowed my husbands concordances and some other theologically based stuff and went to town 🙂 My brain isn’t up to that level of engagement at the moment, but your writing is a tower of awesome.

  2. Kelby Carlson said,


    I really appreciate your engagement with my article, even if it was somewhat indirect. I think its valuable for stories to be share in this arena (and just so you’re aware, I’m a layperson myself!) I’m really busy at the moment, but I would encourage you if you haven’t to take a look at the comment section of the article. Perhaps it won’t help, but i ended up clarifying what I believe to be some of your concersn, particularly the one about disabled people existing to “teach” non-disabled people life lessons.

    I’m so glad you read the article, even if it did make you feel twitchy! It was intended as a conversation-starter, not as the final word, so pushback is appreciated!

    • imfunny2 said,

      the above was meant to reply to Kelby, not Ruth, but here’s a reply to Ruth: Yes, spiritual healing….most often needed, and when that happens often the other pieces follow on in some way…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: