Adaptations that Flicker

December 29, 2009 at 2:04 PM (Uncategorized) (, , , , , , , , , )

There’s a group of four films seen recently on TCM that seem to deal with impairment, and/or confinement.

Also, click on the links for IMDB’s cool trivia about three out of four of these films.

Since these days I’m both I found them newly relevant…

1. First, “The Lion In Winter,” (1968)…about the imprisoned Queen of England in 1183 AD, Eleanor of Aquitaine, which I’ve blogged about before…so I’ll try to stick with relevant stuff.

Henry, her husband, rarely lets her leave her tower, but she is quite capable of using her lands and her sons as pawns in a vengeful game of strategy against the man who ordered the lockup.  She’s appropriate that she only briefly shows how difficult the confinement itself has been for her.

It’s [still] good to be Queen, even when you’re imprisoned.

Patrick Stewart and Glenn Close apparently did a TV version, but…

I’m sorry Patrick, I love you man, but…the 1968 version beats you….

“How kind of you to let me out of jail…”  Katherine Hepburn just kicks so much @zz…

2.  “The Miracle Worker.…” (1962)

I know.  I know.  Helen’s the Ultimate Supercrip, and it’s irritating as hell to be judged against her.  Between Helen and FDR we can’t win.  It doesn’t help that Annie Sullivan is the Plucky Independent Loner, whilst being visually impaired herself…The film is full of stereotyping…and it’s based on a stage play so there’s two levels of Poetic License right there

But…maybe it’s the student in me, but the second that Helen understands language…it’s not violins playing or anything….It just feels like she discovered the Internet of her time, the Way Past her impairments, in the same way the Internet has been the Way Past our impairments…

3. The Enchanted Cottage (1945)  I’m unsurprised that IMDB has no trivia about this movie.

Puke.  Just Puke.

An injured American Pilot must Brood in an Upstairs Room Forever because of some medium scarring of one eye socket and a twisted lip…Life is simply unworthy of living. Until the Homely Upstairs Maid loves him as he is, and he marries her because yanno, impaired men are entitled to their Forever Mommies….

[ Snarky Aside Irrelevant to Film in Question:]

Impaired women?  Suck it up.  You’re on your own.

To his slight credit he does realize quickly enough that he loves her as a woman, not just a caregiver, but that’s not why he proposed, and so I don’t let him off the hook.

The cabin (or the Vaseline on the camera lens) works its magic, and they see each other as unscarred and beautiful even though no physical change has actually occurred…They come out of their delusion, but live happily ever after anyway.

Thank God Robert Young had Marcus Welby MD in his future.

I find it stereotype busting that the oldest film on the list is my favorite…

4. The Barretts of Wimpole Street.

Norma Shearer was always playing these jovial, smart, atypical women…this is no exception.

This is the story of a real woman, Elizabeth Barrett 19th century author.  She  is confined to an upstairs bedroom, with a spaniel as a guard… but is clearly involved in all the little intrigues, joys and angst of her siblings.   While her impairment was never fully figured out in her lifetime (Wikipedia theorizes it was pulmonary stuff of some sort…) she had periods where it affected her more, and some where she was obviously less affected.  She’s quite decent looking, her writing is consistently considered good, published frequently, and opens the door for correspondence with other poets and authors, a really rich varied life of the mind, not just some fantasy.  There’s not much “Oh, the poor thing,” going on from her peers or siblings…they seem to think her impairment serious, but nowhere near death’s door… but her creepy controlling father more than makes up for it. He wants her dependent on him, to “wait for God” to kill her…

I think he loved her a bit too closely, at least in this film version.

I have two favorite parts in the film…

Fellow poet Robert Browning, an able bodied handsome fellow, comes to call and is immediately in love…he makes no apology for it, doesn’t make it some watered down and weird pity for her state.  He loves her, continues as a constant presence in her life and is merrily insistent that they have a future….She makes it downstairs to see him, they wander in the park, she’s much improved (though not ‘cured’) when she’s with him…

The creepy father tries to discourage Browning and his visits — to no avail.  He tries ‘kidnapping’ Elizabeth trying to force her to live away from him and the rest of her friends in another house…He’s just as hideous to another daughter, forbidding her to date, asking Elizabeth to provide a Bible so her sister can swear to him the sister won’t see her lover again.  Elizabeth refuses the use of her mother’s Bible, her first act of open defiance.

And now, my second favorite part:

There is a maid in the household who is in Elizabeth’s corner….Robert has sent a letter that they are to marry that evening, and settle in Italy.  this is the evening before Elizabeth is to be taken to the distant house by her father.  The maid has helped with packing, only she and Elizabeth knowing her real destination.  With her father at dinner, she, her dog, and the maid sneak downstairs with luggage and flee the premises.

Very shortly thereafter the father finishes dinner.  One of his other daughters reads a letter left by Elizabeth for her father, basically politely telling him to kiss off, she’s reaching for happiness…

Unaware she’s taken the dog, the father orders it killed immediately.

The last scene…The Brownings marry.

It’s going to be too “Happily Ever After,” for most people and that’s fine….

But living well while confined…if this is a positive spin on that…we need more.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: